Processing payroll as a small business owner can be overwhelming and time-consuming, but it doesn’t have to be when you partner with the right payroll service provider. The top payroll companies can offer expert guidance and take on the heavy lifting of payroll management, saving you valuable time and resources.

However, what’s more complex is choosing the exemplary payroll services small business owners can rely on for payment processing. There are many options, and each service provider has unique benefits that simplify payroll processing and employee payments. 

This article provides information on the top payroll services small business owners can use to enhance their payroll management. But first, let’s understand the benefits of using payroll services.

Which is The Best Payroll Service for Small Businesses?

Finding the best payroll services small business owners can use for payment processing is crucial to ensure smooth operations for a long time. Here are 10 top payroll solutions that cater specifically to the needs of small businesses:

1. Moorepay

2. Direct Payroll

3. ADP UK

4. Rippling

5. Payescape

6. OneAdvanced

7.mHR

8. Sage Payroll

9. Iris Staffology

10. Creative Payroll Service

What is The Difference Between Payroll Services And Payroll Software?

Payroll services small business owners with a laundry service or a retail shop prefer typically involve outsourcing the entire process to a third-party provider, who manages everything from calculating paychecks to submitting payroll taxes. 

On the other hand, payroll software is a tool that allows businesses to process payroll in-house, providing features like automated calculations, tax filing, and direct deposit.

While such services offer convenience and expertise, payroll software provides more control and customisation options for businesses that prefer to manage payroll internally. Ultimately, the choice between payroll services and software depends on each small business’s specific needs and preferences.

10 Best Payroll Services Small Business Owners Need To Know

Small businesses often face unique challenges when it comes to payroll management. As they grow, the complexity of managing employee wages, tax withholdings, and compliance with labour laws increases. To cater to these needs, here are the top 10 payroll services small business owners can leverage,

1. Moorepay

Source

Moorepay is renowned for its user-friendly payroll services for small—and medium-sized businesses. It offers a complete solution with automated payroll processing, compliance with the latest legislation, and dedicated customer support with real time information.

Why choose Moorepay?

1. Comprehensive service: Supports both part-managed and fully-managed payroll options.
2. Real-time compliance: Ensures adherence to tax regulations and provides regular legislative updates.
3. User-friendly platform: Simplifies the payroll process with easy navigation.

Pros:

1. Extensive support for compliance and payroll management.
2. Custom reporting capabilities.
3. Intuitive interface for seamless operations.

Cons:

1. Pricing is primarily available through quotes.
2. It may not accommodate international payroll needs.

2. Direct Payroll

Source

Direct Payroll is one of the top business payroll services small business owners can use to process payroll directly without involving a third-party payroll provider like Gusto. 

As one of the optimal payroll companies with Direct Payroll, companies can opt for a payroll bureau to handle all aspects of payroll management in-house, from calculating wages and deductions to generating paychecks or initiating direct employee deposits. 

This hands-on approach gives businesses more control over payroll and can be cost-effective in the long run. However, it also requires dedicated resources and expertise to ensure accuracy and compliance with tax regulations.

Why choose Direct Payroll?

1. Efficiency in payroll management: Direct Payroll automates various payroll processes, allowing businesses to handle payroll quickly and accurately. This efficiency minimizes the time spent on administrative tasks, enabling business owners to focus on growth and core operations.
2. Accuracy guaranteed: With built-in automated calculations, Direct Payroll ensures precise payroll processing that reduces the risk of errors in calculations for employee wages, tax withholdings, and deductions. This accuracy is crucial for maintaining employee trust and meeting compliance requirements.
3. Tax compliance: Direct Payroll simplifies basic features like tax filing process by automatically generating required tax forms based on payroll data. This feature saves time and helps businesses comply with local, state, and federal tax regulations, preventing potential penalties.
4. Secure payments: Direct Payroll offers secure direct deposit options to ensure that employees receive their wages safely and promptly. This feature enhances employee satisfaction by providing a modern, convenient payment method that reduces the hassle of physical checks.
5. Scalability: Direct Payroll scales with you as your business expands. Whether adding new employees or opening additional locations, the software can easily accommodate your growing needs without requiring a complete system overhaul.

Pros:

1. Key features like complete control over the payroll management process.
2. Cost-effective solution in the long term.
3. Ability to customise payroll processes according to specific business requirements.
4. Enhanced data security by keeping all payroll information in-house.
5. Opportunity for businesses to develop internal expertise in payroll processing.
6. Direct communication with employees regarding payroll-related matters.
7. Flexibility in adjusting payroll procedures as needed.
8. Potential for faster resolution of payroll issues without third-party involvement.

Cons:

1. Increased workload for internal staff managing payroll.
2. There is a higher risk of errors in payroll calculations without third-party verification.
3. Limited access to specialised payroll expertise and support.
4. Potential challenges in keeping up with constantly changing tax laws and regulations.

3. ADP UK

Source

ADP UK stands out as a good choice for its integrated payroll and HR solutions, catering to businesses of all sizes. It provides extensive features to streamline payroll processes while ensuring compliance and security.

Why choose ADP UK?

1. Integrated platform: Combines payroll with HR management tools.
2. Custom reporting: Delivers tailored insights based on your business needs.
3. Mobile app access: Employees can view payslips and manage time effectively.

Pros:

1. Comprehensive support throughout payroll cycles.
2. Excellent time and attendance tracking features.
3. Flexible plans based on business requirements.

Cons:

1. Pricing may not be transparent upfront.
2. It could become expensive with add-on features.

4. Rippling

Source

Rippling is recognised for its robust integration capabilities. It simplifies payroll processing by allowing businesses to manage employee data, benefits, and payroll all in one place.

Why choose Rippling?

1. Streamlined processing: Automates tasks and calculations to save time.
2. Flexible payroll solutions: Offers various payment options to suit business needs.

Pros:

1. Efficient handling of benefits and payroll in a single interface.
2. Quick integration with third-party software.
3. User-friendly for all experience levels.

Cons:

1. It may have higher costs per employee compared to simpler solutions.
2. There is a slight learning curve for the initial setup if you’re using it for the first time.

5. PayEscape

Source

PayEscape caters specifically to small businesses looking for flexible payroll solutions. Their services include fully managed payroll and HR functionalities with minimal long-term commitments.

Why choose PayEscape?

1. Rolling monthly contracts: Provides flexibility for businesses that want to avoid committing long-term.
2. Comprehensive integration: Works seamlessly with existing accounting software.

Pros:

1. Streamlined payroll processes for ease of use.
2. Strong emphasis on customer support and training.
3. Real-time compliance checks with payroll regulations.

Cons:

1. Limited functionality for handling international payroll.
2. Customization options may be basic compared to competitors.

6. OneAdvanced

Source

OneAdvanced focuses on delivering personalised training and support along with a comprehensive payroll system. This makes it especially valuable for businesses keen on training their staff to manage payroll effectively.

Why choose OneAdvanced?

1. Live training offerings: Helpful for businesses transitioning to a new payroll system.
2. Integrative capabilities: Works well with HR and finance solutions.

Pros:

1. Emphasis on client education and support.
2. CIPP accreditation ensures compliance expertise.
3. Custom reporting is available to suit business needs.

Cons:

1. May need an open API for easy third-party integration.
2. There is no mobile app for employee access like some competitors.

7. MHR

Source

MHR is known for its sophisticated analytics and reporting capabilities. Its payroll platform, iTrent, allows for in-house and outsourced payroll, providing great flexibility for business needs.

Why choose MHR?

1. Advanced reporting features: Tailor reports to analyse employee data comprehensively.
2. Flexible service options: Choose from managed or self-service payroll solutions.

Pros:

1. Robust analytics tools enhance decision-making.
2. Excellent customer service and support options.
3. Customizable functionalities ensure it meets specific business needs.

Cons:

1. Pricing requires quotation, which may deter businesses seeking transparency.
2. Does not offer live training.

8. Sage Payroll

Source

Sage Payroll is designed for simplicity and ensures compliance with Making Tax Digital. Its straightforward interface allows businesses to manage payroll while efficiently benefiting from solid support.

Why choose Sage Payroll?

1. Ease of use: Quick setup and payroll processing.
2. Integrated accounting features: Seamlessly connects with other Sage products.

Pros:

1. Strong customer support and resources available.
2. The affordable pricing model for small to medium businesses.
3. Effective payroll processing engine for quick pay runs.

Cons:

1. Some users may find it limited in advanced features.
2. Additional costs for more comprehensive integrations.

9. Iris Staffology

Source

Staffology by Iris excels at integrating payroll with other business needs, making it a versatile choice for small businesses. It offers transparent pricing and automated submissions to HMRC.

Why choose Iris Staffology?

1. Easy integrations: Works well with various accounting and HR software.
2. Affordable starting price: Clear pricing model starting at £35/month.

Pros:

1. Offers extensive training resources.
2. Live payroll support to resolve issues quickly.
3. Customizable features to align with business requirements.

Cons:

1. May lack certain advanced reporting tools compared to higher-end solutions.
2. Limited payroll change reporting features.

10. Creative Payroll Solutions (CPS)

Source

Creative Payroll Solutions(CPS) offers a competitively priced, fully managed payroll service that targets small businesses. Their uniqueness lies in tailoring packages based on specific needs.

Why choose Creative Payroll Solutions?

1. Affordable pricing: Starting at around £4 per employee per month.
2. Custom packages: Tailored to the size and nature of the business.

Pros:

1. Simple onboarding process.
2. Comprehensive payroll management with high reliability.
3. Excellent customer service with dedicated support.

Cons:

1. May not include some advanced features like reporting capabilities.
2. Limited scalability as the business grows.

How Much Does Outsourcing Payroll Services Cost For Small Businesses?

On average, small businesses can expect to pay between $20 and $200 per month per employee for payroll outsourcing services, which can influence overall payroll costs. 

This cost range factors in

1. Level of service
2. Features included
3. Additional customisation needed

Payroll services small business owners must consider the need to satisfy specific needs and budgets when choosing a payroll service provider. Advanced customisation options and responsive customer support enhance accessibility, and the higher subscription costs could strain your budget. Occasional system downtimes and limited advanced features may challenge complex payroll needs.

This cost varies based on the provider, service level, and customisation required. Ultimately, prioritising a business’s specific needs and budget will guide you in selecting the right payroll service provider for seamless integration and operational efficiency.

What Are The Types of Payroll Services That Small Companies Need?

Small businesses have various payroll service options based on their needs and budget. Here are some common types of payroll services:

1. Fully Managed Payroll Services

This comprehensive option handles all aspects of payroll processing, including tax calculations, direct deposits, wage garnishments, and regulatory compliance. It is ideal for small businesses that outsource payroll functions for maximum convenience and accuracy.

2. Cloud-Based Payroll Software

An online payroll system allows small businesses to manage payroll processes through cloud-based software. It is a great choice for small businesses due to its affordability and flexibility. 

Users can access the system from anywhere with an internet connection, making it convenient for remote work environments. 

Cloud-based software often includes a free trial, automated tax calculations, employee self-service portals, and integration with accounting systems for streamlined financial management.

3. Tax Filing Services

Small and large businesses can opt for payroll services, including tax filing assistance, to ensure compliance with local, state, and federal regulations. 

When selecting the right payroll service provider for your small business, understanding the types of payroll services available is crucial. From fully managed payroll services that handle all aspects of payroll processing to cloud-based payroll software offering flexibility and affordability, there are options to suit every business need.

4. Self-Service Payroll Systems

This type of payroll service empowers small businesses to handle payroll internally using software provided by a third-party provider. It offers flexibility and control over payroll tasks such as processing paychecks, managing tax filings, and generating reports.

5. Online Payroll Services

Online payroll services combine the benefits of automation and cloud technology to streamline payroll processes for small businesses. They typically offer features like direct deposits, tax filing assistance, and employee self-service portals for easy access to payroll information.

Important Payroll Dates in 2024 For Small Businesses in UK

1. Tax Year End – April 5, 2024

2. Deadline for Issuing P60s to Employees – May 31, 2024

3. Deadline for Submitting P11D Forms – July 6, 2024

4. Deadline for Payment of Class 1A National Insurance Contributions – July 22, 2024

5. Deadline for Filing Annual Returns – September 19, 2024

6. Deadline for Submitting Corporation Tax Return – December 31, 2024

Efficient payroll services provided by payroll experts for small business owners are used for effective taxation and payment processing, which requires features that reduce the complexities of tax regulations and compliance deadlines. 

Leveraging self-service or online payroll systems tailored to their needs, including effective payroll data management, can enhance operational efficiency and ensure timely financial management. 

Businesses must mark these important dates in their calendars to avoid penalties or non-compliance issues.

Direct Payroll Services For Small Businesses: Transforming Employee Payments Forever

With the growing demand for skilled professionals, you are bound to expand the team. However, as the team expands, managing their payments becomes complex. Plus, there are tax compliances, labour laws, and complicated calculations to calculate payrolls.

Fortunately, Direct Payroll is one of the leading payroll services, transforming the way you process payroll with automated calculations, compliance, and efficient payments. 

Contact us for more information.

Final Thoughts: Which is The Best Payroll Service Small Business Owners Can Choose?

There are numerous payroll services available that can streamline employee payments for small businesses, each with its advantages and potential drawbacks. Selecting the right service can be challenging, as each option offers unique features that may or may not align with your business’s needs. Therefore, it’s essential to carefully weigh each choice, considering which service best supports your business goals and operational requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should small businesses use a payroll service or payroll software?

Small businesses should use a payroll service or software for several reasons:

1. Efficiency: Payroll services streamline processes, save time, and reduce manual errors in payroll management.

2. Compliance: Payroll services help small businesses adhere to tax regulations and data security standards, ensuring legal compliance.

3. Integration: They can seamlessly integrate with existing accounting software or HR systems, simplifying operations.

4. Customer Support: Payroll services offer reliable customer support for prompt issue resolution and smooth payroll operations.

5. Scalability: These services are scalable to accommodate business growth and changes in workforce size.

Why pricing for payroll services is complex?

Pricing for payroll services small business owners can leverage is often complex due to various factors influencing costs, such as the number of employees, frequency of payroll processing, additional services required, customisation needs, and customer support. 

Each small business has unique requirements that impact pricing, making it essential to carefully evaluate and compare different pricing models to choose the most suitable option, including aspects like performance management and HR features. It’s critical to consider the initial cost and any potential hidden fees or charges that may arise later on to ensure transparency and budget optimisation, thereby reducing the chances of data entry errors.

Which payroll service is the cheapest?

Determining the cheapest payroll services and best payroll software small business owners can use depends on specific business needs and size. Some affordable options for small businesses include Direct Payroll, Gusto, OnPay, and Patriot Software. 

Evaluating the base price and any additional costs for extra features or user support is crucial. Conducting thorough research and comparing offerings can help identify the most cost-effective solution while ensuring all essential payroll requirements are met efficiently.